| Why God, Why?
|
| | Challenge: take a well-known badfic and re-work its premise into something good! | |
|
+23Kakashifan727 spork Disco Stu Miss Jennifer Cunovendus ZOOLANDER Quijotesca Howithurts rae Sheba Harley Quinn hyenaholic EileenK98 ellecue your mom Sakurelf Maximilia patb01 Notanoni Psy-4 Vespers The Unoriginal Braigwen Keith Fraser 27 posters | |
Author | Message |
---|
Quijotesca Sporkbender
Join date : 2010-10-01 Age : 41
| Subject: Re: Challenge: take a well-known badfic and re-work its premise into something good! Mon Oct 10, 2011 7:17 pm | |
| - Howithurts wrote:
- Not quite a badfic, so to speak, but how about those Maradonia chronicles? A well written version of those might be interesting.
Someone's trying that not that I can vouch for it since I can't get past all those fucking horizontal lines. | |
| | | ZOOLANDER Armbiter of Good Fanfiction
Join date : 2010-10-21 Age : 38
| Subject: Re: Challenge: take a well-known badfic and re-work its premise into something good! Fri Oct 21, 2011 2:00 pm | |
| Two words, guys: My Immortal. | |
| | | Cunovendus Sporkbender
Join date : 2011-01-11
| Subject: Re: Challenge: take a well-known badfic and re-work its premise into something good! Sat Jun 16, 2012 3:35 pm | |
| The fic: Full Life Consequences! (it had to be done! ) The premise: John Freeman, Gordon Freeman's brother, joins his brother in the fight to free the world from the results of the catastrophic events at Black Mesa, but his journey takes an unexpected twist. Old summary: John Freeman receives a random email from his brother telling him that "aliens and monsters are attacking his place", and immediately sets off to help him, meeting some totally random encounters along the way. During the struggle, Gordon is killed, and John Freeman replaces him as the "Free Man", and becomes a martyr, due to his ability to perform acrobatic stunts, and "shot" enemies despite having no "wepon". His son becomes the new world's President, and comissions a statue in John's honour, as the "Saver of Humens". New summary: John Freeman, the previously unknown brother of the famous hero Gordon Freeman, finds a mysterious message indicating that his brother is alive, and needs his help. On the way, however, he finds the journey to heroism more difficult than he anticipated, and he is forced to deal with things he could never have imagined, and that could threaten to destroy him and his entire family completely. First chapter here (put in Spoiler tabs due to its length) - I'm trying to stay true to the original story, and keep the original dialogue, as much as possible! - Spoiler:
John Freeman, Gordon Freeman's younger brother, was in his office, during what seemed like an ordinary day at work. It was some 5 years since the controversial incident at Black Mesa, and the mysterious disappearance of Gordon.
In the year 2000, Gordon Freeman, newly graduated, was employed by Black Mesa in the Anomalous Materials department, and was working with the science team. On the day in question, John's last correspondence with Gordon suggested that they had discovered what could potentially be a massive breakthrough in their research, although little information could be confirmed due to confidentiality laws. That was when the emails stopped. John had initially put this sudden ceasation of correspondence down to the fact that Gordon was too busy, or too excited, to find the time to reply. When the third day passed without any response, however, John began to worry. His fears were confirmed when, two days later, news reports spoke of a major catastrophe at the Black Mesa research facility. Most official information was covered up, and the official story was that a series of explosions had simply demolished the facility. Unofficial sources, however, told a different story. According to the few people who claimed to be among the Black Mesa employees who escaped, the resonance cascade itself had only destroyed the test chamber, but had had the after-effect of opening portals to a strange alien world known by the Black Mesa employees as 'Xen'. Little was known about this world or its inhabitants, and what little information they had was soon destroyed when the US Government ordered a clean-up operation, and dispatched marines to the facility with one simple order: "destroy everything". Of the fate of Gordon himself, nothing was known, and many believed him to have died in the attacks. Others swear that this is not the case; one such account states that Gordon portaled into this alien world to fight a creature of great power. It claims that he was successful, and hails Gordon Freeman as a hero. Of his current whereabouts, however, it says nothing.
To this day, therefore, John Freeman had come to accept that his brother had died a heroic death, and a funeral had been held by the Freeman family. Life went on, and over the next five years, John continued to work, pay taxes and live his life as normal. He would often tell stories about the hero Gordon Freeman, from what little information he had, to his wife and his son Henry. Sometimes he would imagine himself falling upon a similar venture, especially when unofficial reports surfaced of strange creatures that they simply called "headcrabs" began to emerge - reports that were often dismissed by those who were not around to witness them.
It was with considerable surprise, therefore, that John received an email from Gordon Freeman. The message was brief, concise and to the point. "Brother, I need your help. You're the only one I trust. Help me defend Ravenholm. I will explain everything later."
John Freeman stared at this email from his brother for several minutes. He couldn't believe what he was reading. Gordon Freeman, alive! Could it be true? Was it merely a sick joke played by some cruel prankster? Or a confidence trick designed to cause him to part with large sums of money? He checked the email again. Directions to Ravenholm were included. After some deliberation, John decided to at least investigate the matter, but the more he thought about it, the more he convinced himself that it was true - his brother was truly alive, and needed his help. John, while no battle-hardened soldier like Gordon, had received basic arms training in the Army Cadets, though it had been some time since he had picked up a firearm, and even longer since he had discharged one - even the pistol he kept for self defence was little more than a deterrent, and had yet to discharge a single bullet in anger.
John shut his computer down, told his supervisor that he had to "take care of some business", and walked briskly down to the car park, where his motorbike was parked. He quickly donned his riding leathers, mounted the vehicle, inserted the key into the ignition, and said to himself:
"It's time to live up to my family name and face full life consequences!"
He didn't know why he said that; it just felt like a good thing to say, since he knew that the symbol adopted by Black Mesa was the Lambda sign used in calculations to designate the half-life of a radioactive isotope (of course, the term "full life" is actually meaningless in this context, but John wasn't to know that). With that, he started the engine. The 50cc cylinders roared into life, and John drove out of the office complex, out of the city and towards the town of Ravenholm, where John Freeman would either rise up to be a great hero like his brother, or meet his fate.
The countryside was serene and beautiful. It was late afternoon, and the sun was beginning to set. It's a good day to do what has to be done, and help my brother defeat the enemies, John thought to himself, as he continued on his journey. He was so lost in his own thoughts, however, that he forgot to regulate his speed, and was soon driving at a velocity that would be considered dangerous for a Nascar circuit. He only realised this, however, when he saw a police car in the distance, lights flashing, barring the road ahead. Sighing, he brought his bike to a stop some twenty yards short of the police vehicle, and waited as the officer approached him.
"I can't give you my license, officer..."
John started to say, but he checked himself immediately as the officer drew closer. The officer wasn't filling out a speeding ticket. He wasn't even hailing him. In fact he wasn't doing anything other than shambling towards him. With a shock, John Freeman realised that he had just seen his first monster, because the thing that approached him was not a police officer at all. It was a headcrab zombie. John slowly reached for the pistol at his belt, his hand shaking uncontrollably. Those things are real! he said to to himself. The headcrab zombie drew closer, and John knew he was going to have to act quickly. He took a deep breath, mustered all of his courage and gripped the holster of the pistol with his hand, using his thumb to disengage the safety.
"I can't give you my license," He said again as his thumb cocked back the firing hammer. Then he whipped the gun out of its holster, yelling, "because you are headcrab zombie!"
John discharged the weapon several times. A bullet struck the headcrab right between what would have been its eyes, if it had any, and the officer - headcrab and all - dropped to the ground and stopped moving. Time seemed to stand still for John Freeman, as he looked at the hideous creature he had just killed. He stood for what felt like over an hour, before he finally pulled himself together. My brother is in trouble, he said to himself. He holstered his gun, re-mounted his motorbike and continued on his way.
After almost an hour of driving, John finally reached Ravenholm. He parked the bike, dismounted and approached what looked like a sign. The sign read 'Welcome to Ravenholm', but written underneath this in what looked like somebody's blood was a hastily scrawled message: 'Yu shudnt com here!'. For a moment, John's courage began to fail him, and he stood rooted to the spot. What am I doing here? He asked himself. I'm no soldier. I'm no hero. I'm just an office worker with a gun. I can't fight these things. He began to turn around, but just then, he heard a scream; a scream that sounded unmistakeably like his brother, in spite of the fact that it had been several years since he had last heard Gordon's voice. John immediately knew why he was here, and forced himself to continue.
Ravenholm was a direct contrast to the serene calm of the countryside. All flora was dead or dying, no animals were present, and the ground was covered in patches of blood. Corpses littered the roads, and dead headcrabs lay around like discarded cigarette butts. John found a discarded MP5 - a sub-automatic firearm capable of discharging bullets with greater speed than his pistol - dropped by an unfortunate man who had failed to heed the warning, and picked it up. He saw movement in the corner of his eye, and instinctively fired the weapon at the approaching zombies. No, he decided, they weren't zombies. They were ghosts...or were they? John couldn't be sure what they were, so he decided that they were "zombie ghosts". Oddly, however, the zombie ghosts made no aggressive move towards him, and the bullets from the weapon failed to harm them. They had reached a stalemate.
"Zombie ghosts!" John yelled, pointing at them, in his best impersonation of a priest. "Leave this place!"
As if in reply, he received a vision - a message imparted by the spirits that seemed to linger here, and he immediately understood. This place was their home, and they were trapped here, unable to depart the realm of the living. He began to feel a strange sympathy for them. He searched around for a solution, and as if by luck, his eyes rested on a bunch of barrels marked with a 'flammable' symbol. There enough of them to demolish the barely stable ruin completely.
"Is this what you need to release you?" John asked. The zombie ghosts imparted an affirmative, and John nodded. Placing the barrels where they would be most effective, he retreated to a safe distance, and with his pistol, shot one of the barrels. The spark ignited the barrel which exploded, igniting the other barrels, and as the zombie ghosts had predicted, they soon demolished what was left of the ruin. The zombie ghosts began to fade, and John could have sworn that he felt a simple message as they departed the world:
"thank you."
John heard another scream, and again he remembered why he was here. He began to follow the sounds of the screaming, picking his way among the corpses, trying his very best to not look down. Eventually he reached Gordon. He was wearing the orange HEV suit that John had seen in photographs that Gordon had sent him, back in the days when communication was more forthcoming, and he was fighting a large creature of great strength and power that John couldn't begin to identify. Several guns of a type John didn't recognise were lying around, apparently discarded, and Gordon had resorted to striking the creature with a crowbar. He saw John at almost the same time John had seen him, and called out to him,
"John! Over here!"
Seeing his brother fighting the thing gave John the courage he needed, and he raised the MP5 and advanced towards the creature, his heart beating at a hundred miles a minute. For a moment, it seemed to look at him - at least he thought it did, for it was difficult to be sure where its eyes actually were. John instinctively pulled the trigger, and the MP5 spat its lethal projectiles at the creature. One of them struck it right in what looked like one of its eyes, causing it to recoil in pain and thrash about wildly. Gordon smiled.
"It's time to end this once and for all!" He yelled, and ended the apparently blinded creature's life with a solid blow from his crowbar.
The two Freeman brothers stood silently for several moments, trying to make some sense of the scene that had just unfolded before them. Suddenly, almost spontaneously, they both began to laugh. John advanced towards Gordon and they hugged.
"Thanks for letting me help, bro!" Said John.
"Try and get here earlier next time," said Gordon, and they began laughing again.
John paused. It did not occur to him that Gordon looked barely older than he had when John saw him last; in fact he didn't look a day older. So many words he had meant to say, so many times he had replayed this moment over in his head - the moment when he would meet his brother again - and now that he was here, he had forgotten all of them. Unfortunately, however, he never got the chance to say any of them, because their reunion was cut short. Gordon's eyes suddenly widened, and his face contorted in terror.
"John! Get out of here!" Gordon yelled. "Run! Fast as you can!"
John ran, expecting Gordon to follow. When he thought he had reached a safe distance, he stopped and looked back, just in time to see Gordon confront a creature that was bigger and mightier than the one they had just killed. Just in time to see Gordon Freeman struck down by the creature. John screamed, and fell to his knees. He felt as though he was trapped in some terrible nightmare from which he could not awaken. Every instinct told him to run, but he could not find the strength to move. The giant creature stared at him for what seemed like an eternity, before apparently deciding he was not worth bothering with, and moving on.
When the creature was out of sight, John finally summoned up every ounce of strength, and ran, out of the park, out of Ravenholm and out of the bad place that was now his brother's grave. He stopped and turned back to face the scene of death before him. Tired, terrified and full of rage all at the same time, he yelled, at the top of his lungs, not caring who was nearby or who heard him:
"I'll get you back evil boss!"
| |
| | | Miss Jennifer
Join date : 2009-06-12
| Subject: Re: Challenge: take a well-known badfic and re-work its premise into something good! Thu Mar 07, 2013 5:42 pm | |
| The fic: Countless Draco/Hermione fics. (Sorry I don't have a specific one to settle on. This re-do is more for a premise than a particular fic.)
Old premise: Draco Malfoy suddenly forgets sixteen years or more of ingrained Muggle/Muggleborn prejudice to fall in True Love with Hermione. (I'm not saying it couldn't be done, but it would probably take a long soul-searching period, maybe even a time of dissociating himself from everything he'd known before as he gets his head together.)
New premise: Draco Malfoy develops an attraction to Hermione Granger...but suffers severe cognitive dissonance when his feelings slam up against his long-held and ingrained beliefs. He can't deal with the fact that he's actually interested in one of THEM, so he blames her for it (filthy Mudblood tramp, trying to tempt me like that! Well, what do you expect from HER kind?) and lashes out at her over it.
See: Goeth, Amon; Frollo, Claude.
Another premise redone:
Old premise: Modern-day girl/woman falls into Middle Earth and thinks it's just so awesome and ends up staying there and finding True Love with (usually) Legolas.
New premise: Modern-day young woman is somehow transported to Middle Earth...but although she is astounded by its beauty and magic, and befriends our heroes (though not to the point of interfering with the storyline--this would take place after the Ring quest), she still longs to return to the home she loves.
At one point, a character asks her, "But you say it's beautiful here...would it be so terrible if you could not return to your own place and time?"
She replies, "I have traveled to beautiful places in my lifetime, but no matter how much I enjoyed seeing these places, it was always a pleasure to return home again...Listen, in my culture, there is an old tale of a peasant girl swept away from her home by a great storm and carried to a land of magic and wonder. This place is beautiful and wondrous, and she makes many close friends there, but her one thought is to return home to the life she loves. Maybe my life back home is a little mundane compared to what I've found here, but it's still mine...the work I enjoy, the friends I've made, the life I've built for myself...and it would break my heart to turn my back on it forever."
(Like the "peasant girl" in the "old tale", she succeeds in the end.) | |
| | | Disco Stu Sporkbender
Join date : 2009-10-22 Age : 40
| Subject: Re: Challenge: take a well-known badfic and re-work its premise into something good! Thu Mar 07, 2013 7:04 pm | |
| So, are you a good witch, or a bad witch? | |
| | | Miss Jennifer
Join date : 2009-06-12
| Subject: Re: Challenge: take a well-known badfic and re-work its premise into something good! Fri Mar 08, 2013 9:18 pm | |
| - Disco Stu wrote:
- So, are you a good witch, or a bad witch?
I'll check with James Franco and get back to you. | |
| | | Cunovendus Sporkbender
Join date : 2011-01-11
| Subject: Re: Challenge: take a well-known badfic and re-work its premise into something good! Sat Mar 09, 2013 2:49 am | |
| The fic: My Immortal!
Old Premise: Ebony Darkness Dementia Ravenway, the most beautiful (and unlikeable) character in the world, falls in love with Draco Malfoy, and the whole world revolves around those two. Half of the cast turn into vampires for no reason whatsoever, Hot Topic opens a branch near Hogwarts, a few emo bands play regular gigs there, and for some reason, Ebony is required to go back in time and attempt to disuade Lord Voldermort from proceeding with his schemes.
New Premise: Ebony Darkness Dementia Ravenway, an incredibly selfish, unlikeable, deluded and mentally unstable prima donna of a girl, develops a crush on Draco Malfoy. At the same time develops a prejudice against anybody she considers a "prep". Somebody mentions vampires in a Magical Creatures lesson, and Ebony begins to wonder what Hogwarts would be like if she, and certain other characters, were vampires, and invents her own imaginary life. She becomes so obsessed with this imaginary life that she is no longer able to tell the difference between it and the real world, and most of the story is about what she wishes happened, while it is made clear that what really happened is very different. It might even switch between the two - her own, and Draco's, points of view telling a very different story. | |
| | | spork Sporkbender
Join date : 2012-06-26
| Subject: Re: Challenge: take a well-known badfic and re-work its premise into something good! Fri Mar 15, 2013 11:14 am | |
| Severus Snape, Professor and Lover (see here)
premise: Severus Snape gets romantically involved with teletubbies.
Old Summary: Snape decides he's had enough of teaching at Hogwarts and resigns. Dumbledoor suggests that he takes a train to a land far away, over the hills. Snape happily takes his advice and ends up in the land of the Teletubbies. Once there, he decides to teach them in strange and erotic ways.
New Summary: Fred and George decide to pull a practical joke on Snape. They illegally smuggle magically animated dolls into school and dress them up as teletubbies. The dolls are set up in a trap on the toilet and when Snape takes a pee in the lunch break, the dolls jump on him, yelling their famous names. Snape is utterly horrified and enraged and attacks them. The dolls manage to escape his wrath and run away below the door. Snape follows them in blind rage, then is caught in the corridor beating on Teletubbies with his pants down by professor McGonagall and a bunch of Griffindor students. Three days later, staff has still not managed to find out who did it and Snape takes out his frustration on Harry Potter by making him demonstrate the effect of a love potion, letting him passionately kiss a frog in front of class. | |
| | | rae Contributor
Join date : 2009-06-10 Location : computer chair
| Subject: Re: Challenge: take a well-known badfic and re-work its premise into something good! Fri Mar 15, 2013 11:38 am | |
| - spork wrote:
- Severus Snape, Professor and Lover (see here)
awesome idea If you end up writing this, definitely post a link. I want to read this! | |
| | | ZOOLANDER Armbiter of Good Fanfiction
Join date : 2010-10-21 Age : 38
| Subject: Re: Challenge: take a well-known badfic and re-work its premise into something good! Sat Mar 16, 2013 4:48 am | |
| - Cunovendus wrote:
- The fic: My Immortal!
Old Premise: Ebony Darkness Dementia Ravenway, the most beautiful (and unlikeable) character in the world, falls in love with Draco Malfoy, and the whole world revolves around those two. Half of the cast turn into vampires for no reason whatsoever, Hot Topic opens a branch near Hogwarts, a few emo bands play regular gigs there, and for some reason, Ebony is required to go back in time and attempt to disuade Lord Voldermort from proceeding with his schemes. Ohhhh, so that's what it was about! I couldn't even get past the first few chapters before my brain started threatening to brick itself and leave me in a permanent coma. - Cunovendus wrote:
New Premise: Ebony Darkness Dementia Ravenway, an incredibly selfish, unlikeable, deluded and mentally unstable prima donna of a girl, develops a crush on Draco Malfoy. At the same time develops a prejudice against anybody she considers a "prep". Somebody mentions vampires in a Magical Creatures lesson, and Ebony begins to wonder what Hogwarts would be like if she, and certain other characters, were vampires, and invents her own imaginary life. She becomes so obsessed with this imaginary life that she is no longer able to tell the difference between it and the real world, and most of the story is about what she wishes happened, while it is made clear that what really happened is very different. It might even switch between the two - her own, and Draco's, points of view telling a very different story. Please make this fic happen. | |
| | | Cunovendus Sporkbender
Join date : 2011-01-11
| Subject: Re: Challenge: take a well-known badfic and re-work its premise into something good! Sat Mar 16, 2013 10:33 am | |
| - xerrofoot wrote:
Ohhhh, so that's what it was about! I couldn't even get past the first few chapters before my brain started threatening to brick itself and leave me in a permanent coma. I listened to Manwithoutabody's reading...there's simply no way I could read through the whole thing. He manages to make it not only bearable, but entertaining! | |
| | | Cunovendus Sporkbender
Join date : 2011-01-11
| Subject: Re: Challenge: take a well-known badfic and re-work its premise into something good! Mon Mar 18, 2013 1:12 pm | |
| - xerrofoot wrote:
Please make this fic happen. Okay, I'll have a go: - Spoiler:
From the diary of Draco Malfoy:
I couldn't stand her. The ridiculously dressed girl was vile, obnoxious, and generally unpleasant to be around. She may be pretty, but after spending roughly five minutes with her, I decided that I'd had enough, and decided to end it.
Unfortunately we didn't see eye-to-eye. The moment I mentioned my desire to separate, she "blew a gasket" (to use a silly muggle expression - a silly expression for a frightfully silly situation), and stormed into a lesson that House Gryffindor were having, accusing that Potter jerk of having sexual relations with me! The very thought that I'd consider such a relationship, and with that Gryffindor rat no less! The drama didn't end there, however; she was promptly escorted out of the classroom, at which point she struggled free and ran out of the building. Silly girl. Apparently she was later found in the Forbidden Forest - I mean, seriously, even the Weasleys aren't stupid enough to go there alone! According to her, she lost her virginity there, and then she met some strange apparition who told her to kill Harry Potter. If only.
The next day, she tried to talk to me again, as if nothing unseemly had happened the day before. She kept talking about some group of muggle musicians called "MCR". Who cares about muggle entertainments anyway? The only thing she ever talks about, other than this group, is how much she hates "preps", which, apparently, includes everybody who doesn't dress in her ridiculous manner and use excessive amounts of makeup. She's so stupid, she gives House Slytherin a bad name. Why couldn't she be sorted into Hufflepuff, with the rest of the morons?
But that's not all - no, the Ebony saga doesn't end there. Now she has this fixation whereby myself, Harry Potter, his mudblood friend Hermione, and somebody called Bloody Mary - or was it Willow? Or Raven? Something stupid like that anyway - and herself, were all vampires! She is clearly suffering from some kind of delusion. She has accused Professor Dumbledore of swearing, the caretaker of trying it on with her, and Professor Snape of taking pictures of her while she was in the bath. I'm sure there's a slander charge in there somewhere. I wonder what rubbish she's going to come up with tomorrow, when she almost certainly tries it on with me again.
She sleeps in a coffin, she drinks a red liquid that she believes is blood, and she changes her clothes ten times a day (not that there's any point in doing so since her entire ensemble is black and looks the same - apparently the standard dress code doesn't apply to her). She's a headcase, and I want nothing to do with her. I'm a Malfoy. I can do better.
I couldn't resist it! [You must be registered and logged in to see this image.] | |
| | | EileenK98 Recovering Fanbrat
Join date : 2009-06-10 Age : 55 Location : very, very close to Chris
| Subject: Re: Challenge: take a well-known badfic and re-work its premise into something good! Mon Mar 18, 2013 6:10 pm | |
| Love it! You should post it to the Pit and see what kind of reaction you get. | |
| | | ZOOLANDER Armbiter of Good Fanfiction
Join date : 2010-10-21 Age : 38
| Subject: Re: Challenge: take a well-known badfic and re-work its premise into something good! Mon Mar 18, 2013 9:51 pm | |
| - Cunovendus wrote:
- xerrofoot wrote:
Please make this fic happen. Okay, I'll have a go:
*excerpt* [You must be registered and logged in to see this image.] | |
| | | Kakashifan727 Sporkbender
Join date : 2012-10-15
| Subject: Re: Challenge: take a well-known badfic and re-work its premise into something good! Tue Mar 19, 2013 2:23 pm | |
| Do it. I want to see what people think. | |
| | | bleachedblackcat Armbiter of Good Fanfiction
Join date : 2009-06-11
| Subject: Re: Challenge: take a well-known badfic and re-work its premise into something good! Tue Mar 19, 2013 3:33 pm | |
| T-that was a masterpiece! *throws roses* | |
| | | ViewSonic Sporkbender
Join date : 2013-05-05 Location : Where the lonely people come from
| Subject: Re: Challenge: take a well-known badfic and re-work its premise into something good! Fri May 31, 2013 11:21 am | |
| I'll have a stab. Text block ahoy!
The Misery Senshi Neo-Zero Double Blitzkrieg Debacle!!!
Premise:
Daria joins the Sailor Senshi. Hi-laaaarious antics ensue.
What happens:
If you can get past the massive "I do not own" disclaimer, including mentioning an encyclopedia of airplane parts, then you will find the crossroads between madness and boredom. Behold! Japanese Neo-Nazis with insane amounts of resources from nowhere! Random crossovers, including a Beavis and Butthead who are now evil rapists instead of listless losers! A blistering black hole that the author thinks passes for comedy! Disturbing fixation on breasts! Three different terrorist organizations, including the Islamic Jihad, most of them stupid! And, worst of all, three OCs with endless backstories, which are told entirely in monologues with LOTS OF EXCLAMATION POINTS!!!!!!! The Dark Kingdom isn't even fucking mentioned.
If it didn't suck:
Japan is facing a threat greater than it ever has before. A new foe from the Dark Kingdom has arisen, stronger and more powerful than any other! Unfortunately, Ami is off in Germany studying to be a doctor...so any random teenage girl off the street will do just fine, including Daria, who out of coincedence is there at the time (school trip). Congratulations Daria, you're the new Sailor Mercury! We get to see a meeting between Brittany and Usagi, and we get an interlude to see the latest Sick Sad World (something ridiculous, no doubt)! Everybody wins! | |
| | | ZOOLANDER Armbiter of Good Fanfiction
Join date : 2010-10-21 Age : 38
| Subject: Re: Challenge: take a well-known badfic and re-work its premise into something good! Fri May 31, 2013 6:15 pm | |
| Sounds like something worth reading. | |
| | | ViewSonic Sporkbender
Join date : 2013-05-05 Location : Where the lonely people come from
| Subject: Re: Challenge: take a well-known badfic and re-work its premise into something good! Mon Nov 11, 2013 12:09 pm | |
| Are we ever going to get another challenge started? We cannot allow WGW to stagnate. | |
| | | Nerdanel Sporkbender
Join date : 2013-11-25
| Subject: Re: Challenge: take a well-known badfic and re-work its premise into something good! Fri Nov 29, 2013 10:02 am | |
| Given my fandoms, it's either legolas by laura or Celebrian, both of which have been mentioned before and are really very terrible. Oh well... So I picked up legolas by laura. It's easy to make that one much less terrible, though quite another to make it good.
Old title: Legolas New title: Laurel's Call
Premise: The plot of the Lord of the Rings is shifted irrevocably when Legolas finds a baby girl in a basket in the woods and takes her home where she becomes his adopted sister. Later the girl is kidnapped by Sauron's forces, and Sauron tries to break her will. He fails, and space not working like it should brings about his doom. Legolas becomes his adopted sister's boyfriend.
Old summary: Legolas finds a baby human in "Milkwood" and names her Laura. She grows up as his adopted sister. Canon characters make pointless cameos. Orcs kidnap Laura and take her to "Mondor" and do bad things to her. Legolas rescues her and Sauron gets defeated because apparently teleportation is now possible in Middle-earth and Gandalf can do it. Legolas becomes Laura's boyfriend and neither them apparently thinks anything about it. Then the fic ends mid-sentence.
New summary: Legolas, patrolling on the edge of the elf territory in Mirkwood, finds the corpse of a woman, recently dead from poison that had come with an orc arrow. Next to the woman Legolas finds a basket lined with laurel, a plant to ward from evil influence, and within the branches a baby girl. Thranduil ends up adopting the girl, and as she grows up, it becomes increasingly apparent that that she isn't human, though she isn't an elf either. The elves of Mirkwood grow disconcerted by her, but girl, who has been named Laurel (I think you could call that something like "crown leaf" in Elvish, as I know those nouns exist), shows no hint of evil. On the other hand, perhaps a great and subtle evil might be able to disguise itself? She becomes a quiet and secretive girl.
One night Laurel feels a strange calling and using her ability to shift between places goes out, curious. A winged Nazgûl comes for her and despite her struggles takes her to Mordor. It turns out that she can't use her powers to escape when she's chained or physically held by another person.
Legolas dreams of Laurel, and sets on a desperate pursuit to rescue her. During the trip he seems to make progress unnaturally fast, and sometimes the scenery becomes ghostly around him. Laurel is calling him to her, and her powers are being spurred to new heights by desperation. Legolas finds himself somehow having sneaked into Barad-dûr. He frees Laurel, and when Sauron himself arrives, she uses her fury and shifts him into a ghostly dimension where he can watch but not intervene.
Laurel wants for Legolas to become her fiancé, and even though the Elven tradition forbids such unions and he sees her as a sister, Legolas doesn't dare to refuse, fearing the change that has come over her. It turns out she was the daughter of Sauron and a strange creature from beneath the roots of the mountains, the sort that Sauron wasn't supposed to know according to Gandalf but turned out to know after all. Sauron didn't create Laurel out of love or lust but as a genetic experiment expected to have unusual powers. Did they just replace the Dark Lord with a Dark Lady? Is Sauron really gone for good? And what about Laurel's mother's kind, now that they know there is an upper world?
------
Laurel is still pretty Sueish in this and most definitely overpowered. But well, if Sauron is going to get defeated in this fic Legolas isn't going to do it, and bringing in Gandalf and the hobbits from the left field would require a reason that makes at least a little bit of sense. And if Sauron isn't going to get defeated, the plot should probably avoid the likes of Mordor and Dor Guldûr altogether, at which point things start getting too far from the original. Well, maybe that approach could work if everything was toned down to a small scale with small stakes and Laura was only abducted by some random Orcs because she was at the wrong place at the wrong time, but that approach would be likely to result in a bland fic in which Laura was still Sueish, just in a passive way.
But as I wrote it, I suppose the story should just play up the eldritch abomination factor. It's okay if eldritch abominations are overpowered. They are supposed to be. | |
| | | Cunovendus Sporkbender
Join date : 2011-01-11
| Subject: Re: Challenge: take a well-known badfic and re-work its premise into something good! Fri Nov 29, 2013 10:16 am | |
| That's an interesting take on the story! It also makes sense, given that, in the original, the orcs capture her for no apparent reason, other than her alleged power (which begs the question: why not kill her, rather than torture and rape her?).
Also, I don't think making a character excessively powerful is, in itself, an automatic Suification. It's more about how the power is used, how the character handles it, how others around her are affected, and (most importantly) how it impacts the original plot of the fandom itself. | |
| | | Nerdanel Sporkbender
Join date : 2013-11-25
| Subject: Re: Challenge: take a well-known badfic and re-work its premise into something good! Fri Nov 29, 2013 10:57 am | |
| - Cunovendus wrote:
- That's an interesting take on the story! It also makes sense, given that, in the original, the orcs capture her for no apparent reason, other than her alleged power (which begs the question: why not kill her, rather than torture and rape her?).
Also, I don't think making a character excessively powerful is, in itself, an automatic Suification. It's more about how the power is used, how the character handles it, how others around her are affected, and (most importantly) how it impacts the original plot of the fandom itself. The original plot of The Lord of the Rings is all about the nigh-impossible task of defeating Sauron. Laurel in my scenario defeats Sauron just like that. Even if Frodo & co. are somewhere with the One Ring, they were just upstaged forever by some OC. And that's bad. I couldn't think of anything better, though. Maybe Laurel could work as a villain and the reason she went to Rivendell with Legolas in the end was to attempt to acquire the One Ring for herself. Villains are always allowed more leeway in power level. Then it would be up to the canon characters to defeat Laurel and Legolas and the remnants of Mordor's strength and whatever other threats might emerge. | |
| | | Cunovendus Sporkbender
Join date : 2011-01-11
| Subject: Re: Challenge: take a well-known badfic and re-work its premise into something good! Fri Nov 29, 2013 12:43 pm | |
| Hmm...could it be modified so that she doesn't actually permanently defeat him, but just inconveniences him in some way? Since the story only really concerns Legolas, it makes less sense to spirit him away from the Fellowship to do something seemingly unrelated, so I'm thinking it'd work as a pre-War of the Ring story that could be a part of the events in which Sauron rose to power, but maybe by rescuing her, Legolas either created a new villain, or inadvertently helped Sauron, or something... Anyway, the idea that Laura/Laurel is actually evil but doesn't know it yet is definitely an interesting take on the story (and probably not the one Laura intended! ). | |
| | | nikore.robinson
Join date : 2013-10-18
| Subject: Re: Challenge: take a well-known badfic and re-work its premise into something good! Tue Oct 07, 2014 1:46 pm | |
| sry for necro
IDK about ye all, but how about some of Mykan's fics? I have wrtten a little original fic about The Seven Dragons/avatars beating up Mykan and his crew into submission (or in Starla and Krysta's case, magpies) | |
| | | Sponsored content
| Subject: Re: Challenge: take a well-known badfic and re-work its premise into something good! | |
| |
| | | | Challenge: take a well-known badfic and re-work its premise into something good! | |
|
Similar topics | |
|
| Permissions in this forum: | You cannot reply to topics in this forum
| |
| |
| |
|